ARLA/CLUSTER: 2009 IARU HF World Championship: LOG de DA0HQ, no es declarado ganador en el concurso.

[Carlos Mourato]

Esta é mais uma prova de que os "five nine" são muitas vezes um embuste. Por
estas e por outras concursos DX em HF para mim ...Não obrigado.

73 de CT4RK


2010/6/11 João Gonçalves Costa <joao.a.costa  ctt.pt>

>
> ---------- Forwarded message ----------
>
> From: URE
> Date: 2010/6/10
> Subject: [iaru-news:1148] 2009 IARU HF World Championship
> To: iaru-news
>
>
> La URE se congratula en saber que sus denuncias de QSO fraudulentos en el
> log de DA0HQ  han sido consideradas correctas y que la ARRL reconozca
> expresamente que numerosos radioaficionados alemanes violaron las reglas del
> concurso, en concreto, tal como dice el CC de la ARRL, la regla 3.5 de sus
> Bases generales para Concursos.
>
> También es motivo de gran satisfacción ver que el LOG de DA0HQ, con cientos
> de contactos fraudulentos, no es declarado ganador en el concurso tal como
> solicitaba la reclamación de la URE. Confiamos en que en breve la DARC
> emitirá un comunicado pidiendo disculpas por el comportamiento antideportivo
> y contrario a las reglas demostrados por varios de sus asociados y secciones
> locales de la DARC.
>
> Sin embargo resulta extraordinariamente descorazonador y vergonzoso ver
> como el CC castiga al resto de HQ cuyo comportamiento en el concurso, tanto
> el suyo como el de sus asociados, fue honesto y cumplidor de las reglas, a
> no recibir el diploma de su correspondiente clasificación obtenida
> limpiamente.
>
> Resulta increíble que el comportamiento antideportivo y contrario a las
> reglas practicado por unos pocos radioaficionados y secciones locales de una
> sola asociación de un solo país haga que el resto de HQ cuyos asociados sí
> tuvieron un comportamiento honesto paguen privándoseles de participar de una
> competición que habían abordado de manera deportiva, legal y limpia. Bajo
> ningún concepto es aceptable la asimilación o extrapolación  del
> comportamiento de unos pocos colegas alemanes al resto de participantes de
> otras nacionalidades.
>
> Agradecemos las muestras de apoyo y solidaridad recibidas en la URE por
> parte de radioaficionados de todo el mundo, especialmente por parte de
> radioaficionados alemanes que están escandalizados por el comportamiento de
> unos pocos de sus compatriotas. Estamos seguros que ese es el sentir de la
> mayoría de sus compañeros en DL. Confiamos que la propia DARC se sumará a la
> repulsa de las practicas que han sido demostradas y corroboradas por el CC.
>
> Agradecemos todas las felicitaciones por nuestro informe recibidas desde
> asociaciones y radioaficionados de todo el mundo. Confiamos que haya sido
> una pequeña ayuda para mantener el Fair Play vivo en nustras competiciones
> deportivas de radio.
>
> Muchas gracias.
>
> ********************************************************
>
>
> The URE is pleased to know that our allegations of fraudulent QSO in the
> log of DA0HQ have been considered correct and that the ARRL Contest Committe
>  recognizes explicitly that numerous German hams violated  the contest
> rules, in particular, as the ARRL Contest Committee mentions, the Rule 3.5
> of its General Rules for Competitions.
>
> It is also gratifying to see that the LOG of DA0HQ, with hundreds of
> fraudulent contacts, is not declared the winner in the competition as
> requested by the claim by URE. We imagine that the DARC will shortly issue a
> statement apologizing for unsportsmanlike and rule-breaking behavior shown
> by several of its members and some local sections of the DARC.
>
> However, it is extremely disheartening and shameful to see how the Contest
> Committe is punishing the rest of HQs in the competition whose behavior,
> -theirs and also that of their respective local members-,   which was honest
> and fully observant of the rules, not to receive a diploma in the
> corresponding classification obtained honestly and fairly.
>
> It is incredible that the unsportsmanlike and rule-breaking behavior
> practiced by just a few amateurs and local branches of a single association
> from a single country (DL), will make the rest of HQs whose members did have
> an honest and rule-compliant behavior deprived from participating in a
> competition in which they had taken part honestly and cleanly. Instead of
> removing those faulty QSO, the Contest Committe condemns the rest of honest
> HQs to not have a reward for their honest work, because just a few in DL did
> break the rules, as confirmed by the CC itself. Under any circumstances, it
> cannot be acceptable any comparison or extrapolation of the behavior of a
> few rulebreakers in Germany with the behavior of the other participants of
> other nationalities, especially of those whose logs have also been analyzed
> publicly.
>
> We appreciate the overwhelming messages of support and solidarity received
> at URE from radio amateurs and associations around the world, especially
> from German hams who are outraged by the behavior of a few of his
> countrymen. We are confident that this is the feeling of the vast majority
> of their peers in DL. We hope that the DARC will soon join the reprobation
> of the practices that have been demonstrated and corroborated by the Contest
> Committee made by few German hams and local sections of the DARC.
>
>  We appreciate very much all the congratulations on our report received
> from associations and radio amateurs around the world. Thanks
>
> also to the Germans hams that helped to show up the truth. We strongly
> believe that this has been for the best interest to keep the Fair Play alive
> in our Radio Sporting events.
>
> Thank you very much.
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> CLUSTER mailing list
> CLUSTER  radio-amador.net
> http://radio-amador.net/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/cluster
>
>


-- 
Best 73 from: regards from: CT4RK Carlos Mourato - Sines - Portugal

Save the Radio Spectrum! Eliminate Broadband over Power Line. Salve o
espectro electromagnético!. Não use a rede electrica para transmitir dados.
Os "homeplugs power line" e a tecnologia "power line" causa fortes
interferencias noutro serviços sem voce se aperceber. Diga não à tecnologia
power line. Proteja o ambiente
-----------------------------------------------------------
-------------- próxima parte ----------
Um anexo em HTML foi limpo...
URL: http://radio-amador.net/pipermail/cluster/attachments/20100611/1c95ffd8/attachment.html